Yesterday I apparently shocked the Twitterverse. In reply to InBabyAttachMode‘s question of why my blogging frequency has been less than people might desire, I replied that being a mommy and a scientist is not really compatible with much else. She asked if I think we’ll ever regret mommy sciencehood and I told her that I suspect that we will. I was also open that I wasn’t sure I would be in academia in six to nine months.
{{Cue the moment when Dr. Isis stomps on the hopes and dreams of ladies everywhere}}
InBabyAttachMode wrote a blog post about the conversation, and this comment line really piqued my interest:
“…it makes me feel that if they can’t do it, then neither can I.”
I started to write a comment, but given the number of emails I am also receiving with comments like “but, you seemed so successful…”, I figured a blog might be more appropriate.
I want to be clear again that whether or not I “can” do something is not the issue.
For me, it really has nothing to do about whether I “can’t” do it. By all feedback that I get from my colleagues, I am a fairly well-respected member of the scientific community, a good teacher, etc, etac, etc.
The question for me is what I find fulfilling and how important is that to me compared to how I am rewarded. I’ve been within the walls of the ivory tower for more than a decade and I’m at a point now where I have the opportunity to really consider whether I want to try something new. It’s not unusual in every place but academia for people to look at their careers and say, “Is this really what I want to be doing?” The fact that my career pondering was so shocking to people on Twitter, I would argue, is reflective of mores and atitudes that are unique to academia.
It’s been interesting to me to look back at the endless optimism I blogged with five years ago. It’s not entirely gone, but it has certainly evolved toward practicality. Being an academic scientist (for me) does necessarily mean sacrificing some time with my family. I applaud the people who can do their job in forty hours. That has never been my reality. So, if I am going to be working as hard as I am at the expense of time with my family, it’s worth asking whether it’s really something I want to be doing. Right now I’m not so sure it is. But, maybe it is. As I shared with someone by email, maybe my grass really is the greenest. Or, maybe I’d rather be a fighter pilot, or a porn writer, or a French chef. When we’re training, we are so focused on reaching the dream that it’s impossible to realize that, holy fuck, this is a job that a lot of people do until they die.
But, I’ll tell you, dear readers, that I have also found the reactions of the scientist-o-sphere in general to be disturbing. I have been nothing but honest with you all about my optimisms and my failings, but I am not the holy grail of women scientists. The fact that I have chosen to reconsider my career and happiness is by no means some indication that women in general can’t be successful or happy in science.
You can’t rest your hopes and aspirations for an entire profession on the shoulders of a single person. Franky, it’s not fair to her and you’re likely to be disappointed.
Like this:
Like Loading...